I tried making my own chokers, and it really works!! I took an old pair of my daughters, probably about a size 4, and cut them a little over an inch wide(1/2 inch just looked too thin at the time). It's really small, but I got it over my six year old's head!! I would suggest NOT using a toddler sized pair of tights, but it really does work!!
And it rolls up, just like Christie said it would. You can't tell it's cut from a pair of tights.
It kind of reminds me of those things we used to weave pot holders with when we were little girls. KWIM??
Thanks, Christie for the tute!!